The Prosperity Gospel's Body Count: When Fake Faith Kills Real Souls by Jeff Callaway

The Prosperity Gospel's Body Count: When Fake Faith Kills Real Souls

By Jeff Callaway

Texas Outlaw Poet

I. A Different Kind of Death Toll

There are corpses piled high in Joel Osteen's megachurch, but nobody's counting them. Not because they're invisible, but because most folks don't know what a spiritually dead man looks like when he's still breathing, smiling, and depositing his tithe check every Sunday morning.

Let me be clear about what I mean by body count. I'm not talking metaphors. I'm not being poetic. I'm talking about actual, eternal, soul-crushing death. The kind where a man stands before Christ on judgment day and hears words that will echo through eternity: "I never knew you. Depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness."

Christ Himself warned us about this spiritual slaughter. In Matthew 7, He painted a picture that should make every comfortable Christian squirm in their padded pew. He spoke of a narrow gate and a wide road. He warned about false prophets who come dressed in sheep's wool but have wolf teeth dripping with blood. And He said something that should shake every single person who calls Joel Osteen "pastor" right down to their bones:

"Not everyone who says to Me, 'Lord, Lord,' shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father in heaven. Many will say to Me in that day, 'Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?' And then I will declare to them, 'I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness!'"

Many. Not a few. Not some. Many. That word should terrify anyone who preaches a gospel that looks nothing like the one Christ died for.

The prosperity gospel doesn't merely mislead lost souls wandering in darkness. It actively replaces the living Christ with a golden calf named Mammon. It takes the scandalous, blood-soaked, dirt-poor gospel of a crucified carpenter and transforms it into a slick motivational seminar where God exists to boost your bank account and inflate your ego.

Paul of Tarsus, writing under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, put it plainly in his letter to the Galatians: "I marvel that you are so soon removed from Him who called you into the grace of Christ, to a different gospel, which is not another; but there are some who trouble you and want to pervert the gospel of Christ. But even if we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel to you than what we have preached to you, let him be accursed. As we have said before, so now I say again, if anyone preaches any other gospel to you than what you have received, let him be accursed."

Accursed. That's not my word. That's Scripture's word. And it applies to every man who stands in a pulpit and tells suffering people that their poverty proves God doesn't love them, that their sickness reveals their lack of faith, that Christ died so they could drive a luxury car and live in a mansion.

II. What the Prosperity Gospel Actually Teaches

Let's lay out what these wolves actually preach when they're not hiding behind their veneered smiles and carefully crafted PR statements.

The Core Lies

First, they teach that wealth equals divine favor. If you're rich, God loves you. If you're poor, well, you must be doing something wrong. This theology would have confused the Apostle Paul, who said he learned to be content in whatever state he found himself, whether abounding or suffering need. It would have baffled Peter, who left his fishing nets and never looked back. It would have bewildered John the Baptist, who wore camel hair and ate locusts in the wilderness.

Second, they claim poverty and sickness result from lack of faith or negative confession. Got cancer? You must not be believing hard enough. Lost your job? Stop speaking those negative words into existence. Your child died? Well, maybe if you'd planted that seed offering when the preacher asked, God would have intervened. This is spiritual terrorism dressed up as encouragement.

Third, they insist God's primary will for your life is comfort, success, and self-esteem. Not holiness. Not sanctification. Not conformity to Christ's image. Just feeling good about yourself and having nice things. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches something radically different in paragraph 2544: "Jesus enjoins His disciples to prefer Him to everything and everyone, and bids them renounce all that they have for His sake and that of the Gospel."

Fourth, they reduce faith to a technique, a mechanism to obtain material outcomes. Say the right words. Think the right thoughts. Plant the right seed. And God, like some cosmic vending machine, will dispense the blessings. This isn't Christianity. It's Gnosticism wearing a cross pendant.

Why This Is Damnable Heresy, Not Just Bad Theology

The Catechism addresses this directly when it condemns idolatry in paragraphs 2112-2114. Idolatry doesn't just mean bowing to statues. It means treating anything as ultimate that isn't God. When you treat God as a tool to get wealth, you've committed idolatry. When you make prosperity the goal and God the means, you've built a golden calf.

The Church also rejects what the Catechism calls "secularized messianism" in paragraph 676 – the idea that mankind can achieve paradise on earth through human effort, technique, or positive thinking. The prosperity gospel is exactly this heresy: the promise that you can create heaven now through the power of your words and your wallet.

But here's what really damns the prosperity gospel: it eliminates the redemptive meaning of suffering. The Catechism teaches in paragraphs 1508-1510 that Christ gave suffering a new meaning through His passion and death. Suffering can now configure us to Christ and unite us with His redemptive passion. The prosperity gospel calls this teaching demonic. It insists all suffering is from Satan and can be rebuked away with enough faith.

Tell that to the martyrs. Tell that to the saints who embraced poverty. Tell that to Christ hanging on the Cross.

III. Joel Osteen: The Smiling Face of Spiritual Murder

Now we come to the main act: Joel Osteen, the pastor of America's largest church, the man with the million-dollar smile and the theology that couldn't save a goldfish.

What Osteen Actually Preaches

Let's examine the public record. This isn't speculation or character assassination. These are Osteen's own documented words and systematic omissions.

Joel Osteen persistently refuses to preach about sin. He admits it openly. In interviews, he says he doesn't talk about hell, damnation, or anything "hard to hear" because people are already beaten down enough. He wants them to feel better about themselves.

He systematically avoids calling people to repentance. Search his sermons. You'll find endless talk about claiming your blessings, receiving your miracle, living your best life now. You know what you won't find? A single clear call to turn from sin, die to self, and follow Christ.

He will not preach on judgment. When pressed by interviewers about whether people who reject Christ go to hell, Osteen fumbles, deflects, and ultimately says he doesn't know. He can't say. Only God can judge a person's heart.

Most damningly, Osteen preaches a gospel without the Cross as sacrifice. Yes, he mentions Jesus. Yes, he uses Christian vocabulary. But the central reality of Christianity – that Christ died as a propitiation for our sins, bearing God's wrath in our place – is conspicuously absent.

The Fatal Absence: The Cross

Compare Osteen's message with Luke 9:23: "Then He said to them all, 'If anyone desires to come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross daily, and follow Me.'"

Deny yourself. Take up your cross. Follow Me.

That's Christianity. That's the gospel. That's what Christ demands.

Now compare that with Osteen's theology: Affirm yourself. Claim your blessings. Live your best life now.

These aren't variations of the same message. They're antithetical. They cannot coexist. One is Christ's gospel. The other is a gospel from hell dressed in Sunday morning clothes.

Paul wrote in 1 Corinthians 1:18: "For the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God." The Cross isn't optional. It isn't something you mention in passing between your seven keys to promotion and your five steps to breakthrough. The Cross is the absolute center, the scandal, the stumbling block, the power of God unto salvation.

Without the Cross, there is no Christianity. Without blood, there is no remission of sins. Without death, there is no resurrection. Without suffering, there is no glory.

Osteen's gospel has no suffering, which means it has no glory. It has no death, which means it has no resurrection. It has no blood, which means it has no salvation.

The Scandal of Silence

But Osteen's defenders will say, "He's just being positive. He's trying to encourage people. Not everyone has to preach the same way."

Wrong. Dead wrong.

The Catechism is clear in paragraphs 2471-2472 about the duty to bear witness to truth. Every Christian, but especially those in teaching positions, has an obligation to speak the truth of the Gospel clearly, completely, and without compromise. Silence about sin isn't kindness. It's cruelty. Refusing to warn people about judgment isn't love. It's negligence.

Christ never avoided hard truth to maintain crowd size. In John 6, after teaching difficult doctrine about eating His flesh and drinking His blood, many of His disciples turned away. Jesus didn't chase after them with a softer message. He turned to the Twelve and asked, "Do you also want to go away?"

The Catechism warns in paragraph 675 that the final trial of the Church will involve religious deception offering men an apparent solution to their problems at the price of apostasy from the truth. The prosperity gospel is exactly this deception: a feel-good religion that solves all your earthly problems while damning your eternal soul.

IV. By Their Fruits: The Real Damage

Jesus said you'll know false prophets by their fruits. So let's examine the harvest of the prosperity gospel.

Spiritual Carnage

First, it creates presumption of salvation. The Catechism warns against presumption in paragraph 2092, defining it as either presuming upon God's mercy without conversion and perseverance, or thinking one can save oneself without God's grace. Prosperity gospel produces both. People presume they're saved because they said a prayer, attended church, and claimed their blessings, all without ever truly repenting or surrendering to Christ as Lord.

Second, faith collapses when suffering comes. And suffering always comes. When it does, people raised on prosperity theology face a crisis: either God lied, or they didn't have enough faith. Many choose the former and abandon Christianity entirely. Others sink into guilt and self-condemnation, convinced their suffering is punishment for hidden sin or weak faith.

Third, it produces abandonment of God when the formula fails. Plant a seed, get a harvest. Confess it, possess it. Name it, claim it. But what happens when you plant and nothing grows? When you confess and nothing changes? When you name it and claim it and still bury your child? People conclude God is a liar and Christianity is a scam.

Psychological and Moral Destruction

The prosperity gospel engages in systematic victim-blaming of the poor and sick. If wealth equals God's favor, then poverty equals God's disfavor. If health proves faith, then sickness proves unbelief. This theology looks at Lazarus covered in sores at the rich man's gate and says, "He must not be praying hard enough."

It crushes people with guilt over unanswered prayers. Your child wasn't healed because you didn't believe hard enough. Your business failed because you had doubt. Your marriage crumbled because you spoke negative words. This is demonic.

And it breeds subtle contempt for the weak. If God blesses the faithful with wealth, then the poor must be unfaithful. If health follows true belief, then the sick must be in unbelief. This theology produces Pharisees who thank God they're not like other men, especially those wretched poor and sick people.

Ecclesial Devastation

The prosperity gospel transforms church into a motivational seminar. Preaching becomes performance. The pulpit becomes a stage. And the congregation becomes an audience, not the Body of Christ.

Worship becomes entertainment. We measure success by attendance numbers, building size, and budget totals. We evaluate preachers by their charisma, not their fidelity to Scripture. We choose churches like we choose restaurants: based on how they make us feel.

And Christ becomes optional. He's mentioned, certainly. His name is invoked. But the actual, historical, crucified and risen Jesus – the One who said the poor are blessed, who warned that the rich will hardly enter the Kingdom, who promised His followers persecution and tribulation – that Jesus is nowhere to be found.

V. Scripture's Total Rejection

Let me pile up Scripture like stones. Let the weight of God's Word crush the prosperity gospel into dust.

Christ on Wealth

Matthew 6:19-24: "Do not lay up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy and where thieves break in and steal; but lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven... For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also... No one can serve two masters; for either he will hate the one and love the other, or else he will be loyal to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve God and mammon."

Luke 12:15: "Take heed and beware of covetousness, for one's life does not consist in the abundance of the things he possesses."

Mark 10:23-25: "How hard it is for those who have riches to enter the kingdom of God! It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God."

The Apostles on Prosperity Theology

1 Timothy 6:5-10: "Godliness with contentment is great gain. For we brought nothing into this world, and it is certain we can carry nothing out. But those who desire to be rich fall into temptation and a snare, and into many foolish and harmful lusts which drown men in destruction and perdition. For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil, for which some have strayed from the faith in their greediness, and pierced themselves through with many sorrows."

James 5:1-6: "Come now, you rich, weep and howl for your miseries that are coming upon you! Your riches are corrupted, and your garments are moth-eaten. Your gold and silver are corroded, and their corrosion will be a witness against you and will eat your flesh like fire."

2 Corinthians 12:7-10: Paul speaks of his thorn in the flesh, asking God three times to remove it. God's response? "My grace is sufficient for you, for My strength is made perfect in weakness." Paul concludes: "Therefore most gladly I will rather boast in my infirmities, that the power of Christ may rest upon me."

The Beatitudes Destroy Prosperity Theology

Matthew 5:3: "Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven."

Not blessed are those who claim their wealth. Not blessed are those who confess prosperity. Blessed are the poor in spirit.

This isn't metaphorical comfort. This is actual, radical detachment from worldly goods. The Catechism teaches in paragraph 2544 that "the precept of detachment from riches is obligatory for entrance into the Kingdom of heaven."

VI. The Fathers and Doctors: Two Thousand Years of Condemnation

The prosperity gospel isn't new. It's as old as Simon Magus trying to buy the power of the Holy Spirit. And for two thousand years, the Church has condemned it with one voice.

Saint John Chrysostom

This fourth-century preacher, called "Golden-Mouthed" for his eloquence, devoted multiple homilies to destroying the theology that wealth equals God's blessing.

In his sermons on the parable of Lazarus and the rich man, Chrysostom thundered: "Not to share our own wealth with the poor is theft from the poor and deprivation of their means of life; we do not possess our own wealth but theirs."

He taught that the rich must hold property as stewards for the poor, and must share wealth without regard to the moral qualities of those in need. He said if we spend more than necessary on ourselves, we deserve the same penalty as if we had stolen the money.

Chrysostom looked at the wealthy of his day spending fortunes on silver chamber pots while the poor starved, and he roared: "When Christ is famishing, do you revel in such luxury, act so foolishly? Another, made after the image of God, is perishing of cold; and you're furnishing yourself with such things as these?"

Saint Augustine

The bishop of Hippo taught that disordered love is the root of sin. When we love created things more than the Creator, we commit idolatry. When we use God to get things rather than loving God for Himself, we prove we never knew Him.

Augustine would look at the prosperity gospel and see it instantly for what it is: using God as a means to acquire creation. This is the essence of sin.

Saint Thomas Aquinas

The Angelic Doctor systematically demolished every argument for wealth-seeking as godliness. He taught that avarice is a capital sin precisely because it makes temporal goods into ultimate ends rather than means to holiness.

Aquinas would say the prosperity preacher commits the sin of simony – trying to purchase spiritual power with material wealth, or worse, trying to sell God's blessings for money.

VII. Why This Is Formal Heresy

Let me be precise here. The prosperity gospel isn't just wrong. It isn't just bad theology. It's formal heresy – a teaching that directly contradicts defined Catholic doctrine.

What It Distorts

It distorts God's nature, making Him a cosmic sugar daddy who exists to fulfill our desires rather than the sovereign Lord who demands our total surrender.

It distorts salvation, making it about temporal blessing rather than eternal life, about earthly prosperity rather than heavenly glory.

It distorts grace, making it something we can manipulate through technique rather than God's free gift.

It distorts suffering, calling evil what God calls redemptive, rejecting what Christ embraced.

And it distorts the Cross, making it background scenery rather than the absolute center of all reality.

What It Replaces

The prosperity gospel replaces repentance with affirmation. Instead of "Repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand," it preaches, "Believe in yourself, for your breakthrough is coming."

It replaces sanctification with success. Instead of being conformed to Christ's image through suffering, you're molded into the image of successful businessmen through positive thinking.

It replaces holiness with happiness. The goal isn't to be like Christ. The goal is to feel good.

The Catechism teaches that sin is "an offense against reason, truth, and right conscience; it is failure in genuine love for God and neighbor caused by a perverse attachment to certain goods" (CCC 1849). The prosperity gospel is exactly this: a perverse attachment to material goods that masquerades as love for God.

The Catechism warns against presumption in paragraph 2092: hoping to obtain forgiveness without conversion and glory without merit. The prosperity gospel is pure presumption: claiming God's blessings without true repentance, expecting heaven while living for earth.

VIII. The Catholic Church: The Anti-Prosperity Gospel

Now let me show you what real Christianity looks like.

What the Church Actually Offers

The Catholic Church doesn't promise you riches. She promises you a suffering Savior who calls you to take up your cross.

She doesn't offer you techniques to manipulate God. She offers you sacramental grace that transforms your soul.

She doesn't give you motivational speeches. She gives you moral clarity that exposes sin and calls you to repentance.

And she gives you a theology that works when life falls apart. When you're diagnosed with cancer, when your child dies, when you lose everything – the prosperity gospel crumbles into ash. But the Catholic faith? It stands firm because it's built on the Rock of a crucified God who understands suffering from the inside.

The Catechism teaches that through suffering we can be configured to Christ and united with His redemptive passion (CCC 1505). This means suffering isn't meaningless. It isn't evidence that God abandoned you. It's an invitation to participate in the most profound reality in the universe: the Cross of Christ.

The Saints: Living Proof

Want to see what God actually blesses? Look at the saints.

Saint Francis of Assisi was the son of a wealthy merchant. He could have lived in prosperity. Instead, he stripped naked in the public square, gave everything to the poor, and embraced Lady Poverty. He kissed lepers. He begged for bread. He died owning nothing. And he's one of the most beloved saints in Church history.

Saint Mother Teresa of Calcutta ministered to the dying in the gutters of India. She owned two saris. She lived in conditions most Americans would call poverty. And in her private writings, revealed after her death, we learned she experienced spiritual darkness for decades. By prosperity gospel standards, she had weak faith. By Catholic standards, she's a saint.

Saint Maximilian Kolbe died in a Nazi concentration camp, murdered for offering to take another man's place in the starvation bunker. He had no wealth. He died in agony. But he's a martyr and a saint.

None of them were wealthy. But all of them were free. Free from the love of money. Free from the fear of suffering. Free to love God with reckless abandon.

Compare them to Joel Osteen living in a $10.5 million mansion while preaching that God wants you to prosper. Compare them to prosperity preachers flying in private jets while their followers struggle to pay rent. Compare them to megachurch pastors building crystal cathedrals to themselves while Christ said He had nowhere to lay His head.

IX. Final Warning and Invitation

Christ did not come to make you rich. He came to make you holy. He didn't die on a cross so you could drive a luxury car and live in a mansion. He died so you could be reconciled to God and transformed into His image.

The prosperity gospel whispers in your ear: "Claim your blessing. Receive your breakthrough. Name it and claim it."

But Christ thunders from the Cross: "If anyone desires to come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross daily, and follow Me."

There's a church that's been standing for 2,000 years, built on the foundation of apostles and prophets with Christ Jesus Himself as the cornerstone. She doesn't promise you earthly wealth. She promises you eternal life. She doesn't guarantee you health and prosperity. She guarantees you the sacraments, the truth, and the narrow road that leads to life.

That church is the Catholic Church. The Church that never promised comfort, only truth. The Church that produces saints, not millionaires. The Church that carries the Cross, not a checkbook.

The prosperity gospel is a broad road that looks easy, feels good, and leads straight to destruction. Thousands walk it. Millions follow the preachers who peddle it. But it ends at a cliff, and over that cliff is eternal separation from God.

Matthew 7:21: "Not everyone who says to Me, 'Lord, Lord,' shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father in heaven."

What is the Father's will? Repentance. Faith in Christ crucified. Taking up your cross. Dying to self. Being born again not into prosperity, but into holiness.

This is the call. Not to claim your blessing, but to deny yourself. Not to receive your breakthrough, but to take up your cross. Not to live your best life now, but to follow Christ even unto death, trusting that in losing your life you will find it.

The prosperity gospel has killed enough souls. It's time to call it what it is: damnable heresy. It's time to reject Joel Osteen and every preacher like him. It's time to turn away from the broad road and find the narrow gate.

And it's time to come home. To the Church. To the truth. To the Cross. To Christ.

The invitation stands. The door is open. But you have to choose. You cannot serve God and mammon. You cannot follow Christ and chase prosperity. You cannot take up your cross and live your best life now.

Choose this day whom you will serve. But as for me and my house, we will serve the Lord who hung on a tree, died in poverty, and rose in glory. Not the false Christ of the prosperity gospel, but the true Christ of Scripture, Tradition, and the Catholic Church.

Come home. The truth is waiting.

~ Jeff Callaway

Texas Outlaw Poet

© 2025 Texas Outlaw Press. All rights reserved.

https://texasoutlawpress.org