The Lie Martin Luther Left You: Why You’re Still in Danger by Jeff Callaway

The Lie Martin Luther Left You: Why You’re Still in Danger

By Jeff Callaway

Texas Outlaw Poet

I grew up believing a lie.

A comfortable, easy lie that thousands of well-meaning preachers told me every Sunday morning in churches scattered across Texas and beyond. They said salvation was simple. Just say the magic words. Accept Jesus into your heart. Pray the sinner's prayer. Walk that aisle during the altar call. Sign that card. Done. Saved. Forever. No takebacks. Heaven guaranteed. Eternal fire insurance purchased with a thirty-second prayer.

I watched people walk forward, pray the prayer, get baptized the next Sunday, and then never change. Same sins. Same habits. Same lives. But they had assurance. They were going to Heaven because they had prayed the prayer. They were once saved, always saved. Nothing could change that. Not adultery. Not drunkenness. Not abandoning the faith entirely. Because five years ago, or ten years ago, or thirty years ago, they had walked an aisle and meant it.

Then I discovered something that shook me to my core.

I discovered that Christ actually founded a Church. Not a loose association of independent congregations making up their own rules as they went along. Not a spiritual democracy where every man with a Bible interprets Scripture however he pleases and calls it the leading of the Holy Spirit. But a real, visible, hierarchical Church with authority to bind and loose, to teach and correct, to administer the sacraments He Himself instituted.

I discovered the Eucharist. The real presence of Christ. His actual Body and Blood offered in the Mass, not as a symbol or a memorial, but as true food for the journey. And I realized that for my entire Protestant life, I had been starving spiritually while thinking I was fed.

I discovered sacramental confession. The power Christ gave His apostles to forgive sins in His name. And I realized that all those years of confessing my sins to God in my bedroom, hoping He heard me, trusting my feelings that I was forgiven, I had been missing the concrete assurance Christ established.

And that's when the comfortable lie started to crumble.

That's when I began to understand that Protestantism, for all its talk of grace and faith and Jesus, had cut itself off from the very means of grace that Christ instituted. And in doing so, it had placed millions of souls in spiritual danger.

The Protestant Promise: Easy Salvation, No Strings Attached

Walk into any Protestant church in America and you'll hear some version of the same story. Salvation is a done deal. One prayer, one moment of belief, and you're locked in for eternity. They call it being born again. Getting saved. Accepting Jesus as your personal Lord and Savior.

The implication is clear: once you've said those words, believed in your heart, walked that aisle or raised that hand, you're guaranteed Heaven. Nothing can change it. Not sin, not apostasy, not even denying Christ Himself. Because if you could lose salvation, they argue, then it wasn't really grace at all.

It sounds beautiful. Comforting. Secure.

It's also spiritually deadly.

This doctrine, unknown to Christianity for fifteen hundred years until John Calvin invented it in the sixteenth century, has sent more souls careening toward Hell than perhaps any other Protestant innovation. Not because God's grace isn't sufficient. Not because Christ's sacrifice wasn't complete. But because it teaches Christians to lower their guard, to stop fighting sin, to assume they're safe when they might be standing on the edge of a cliff with their eyes closed.

What The Catholic Church Actually Teaches About Salvation

Before we dive deeper into why Protestantism places souls at risk, we need to understand what the Catholic Church actually teaches. Because despite what many Protestants believe, the Church doesn't teach that we earn our way to Heaven through good works.

The Church teaches that salvation comes through Christ alone. His sacrifice on Calvary is the sole source of redemption. Without His grace, we can do nothing. The Catechism states clearly that all salvation comes from Christ the Head through the Church which is His Body.

But here's where it gets serious. The Church also teaches truths that Protestantism has abandoned:

Mortal sin exists. The Catechism teaches that mortal sin destroys charity in the heart of man by a grave violation of God's law. It turns man away from God and results in the loss of sanctifying grace. If unredeemed by repentance and God's forgiveness, it causes exclusion from Christ's kingdom and the eternal death of Hell.

We must persevere to the end. Faith isn't a one-time decision. It's a lifelong journey. As Scripture says, he who endures to the end will be saved. Not he who once believed. He who endures.

The sacraments are necessary. Christ instituted the sacraments as ordinary means of grace. Baptism for regeneration. Confession for the forgiveness of sins after baptism. The Eucharist as true food for the journey. These aren't optional extras. They're how Christ Himself dispenses His grace.

Sanctifying grace can be lost. Through mortal sin, a person in the state of grace can fall from that grace and need to be restored through sacramental confession. Grace isn't a permanent stamp on your soul that nothing can erase.

Now comes the critical distinction that many Protestants misunderstand. The Church teaches that those who through no fault of their own do not know Christ and His Church, but nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, may achieve eternal salvation. This is called invincible ignorance.

But notice the condition: through no fault of their own. If you've been shown the truth about the Catholic Church, if you've encountered the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist, if you've studied Church history and discovered that the Catholic Church is the Church Christ founded, and you reject it? That's not invincible ignorance. That's culpable rejection of known truth.

And the stakes couldn't be higher.

The Spiritual Danger of Protestantism Itself

Let me be crystal clear: I'm not saying every Protestant is damned. God forbid. Many Protestants love Jesus with everything they have. God is merciful. He judges the heart.

But Protestantism as a system places souls in grave danger. Here's how:

The Rejection of the Church Christ Founded

Jesus didn't write a book and scatter it across the earth. He founded a Church. He told Peter, "You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of Hell shall not prevail against it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven."

He told the apostles, "He who hears you hears me, and he who rejects you rejects me." He sent the Holy Spirit to guide the Church into all truth.

For fifteen centuries, Christianity meant one thing: the Catholic Church. Even the Orthodox maintained apostolic succession, valid sacraments, and hierarchical structure.

But Protestantism shattered that unity into thousands of fragments.

Today there are over forty thousand Protestant denominations, each claiming to be led by the Holy Spirit, each interpreting Scripture differently. Some baptize infants, others don't. Some believe in real presence, others say it's symbolic. They can't even agree on what the Gospel is or how you're saved.

How can this possibly be what Christ intended?

When Martin Luther nailed his ninety-five theses to the church door in 1517, he made a fatal error: he rejected the teaching authority of the Church. He elevated his own private interpretation of Scripture above the magisterium. He made himself the final authority.

And once that door was opened, there was no way to close it. If Luther could reject Rome's authority, why couldn't Zwingli reject Luther's? And why couldn't Calvin reject Zwingli? And on and on it went, fracture after fracture, until we have the chaos we see today.

When you reject the teaching authority Christ gave to His Church, you're left with private judgment. Scripture itself warns that no prophecy of Scripture is a matter of private interpretation.

The Rejection of the Eucharist: Refusing the Food of Eternal Life

This might be the most tragic loss in Protestantism. The abandonment of belief in the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist.

Jesus couldn't have been clearer. In John chapter six, He said, "I am the living bread that came down from heaven. Whoever eats of this bread will live forever. And the bread that I will give for the life of the world is my flesh."

The Jews quarreled, saying, "How can this man give us his flesh to eat?"

Jesus didn't back down. He doubled down. "Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you. Whoever feeds on my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life. For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink."

The Greek word John uses is trogo, which means to gnaw on, to chew. This isn't symbolic language. And we know this because when Jesus said it, many of His disciples turned away. They said, "This teaching is hard; who can accept it?" And Jesus didn't call them back and say He was speaking metaphorically. He let them leave.

The early Church believed unanimously in the real presence. Read Ignatius of Antioch, who learned from the Apostle John himself. Writing around 110 AD, he said the Eucharist is the flesh of our Savior Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins. He condemned heretics who denied the real presence.

Read Justin Martyr, who wrote around 150 AD. He said, "Not as common bread and common drink do we receive these, but since Jesus Christ our Savior was made incarnate by the word of God and had both flesh and blood for our salvation, so too the food which has been made into the Eucharist is both the flesh and the blood of that incarnated Jesus."

For fifteen hundred years, Christians believed that when the priest consecrated bread and wine at Mass, they became Christ Himself. Then the Protestant Reformation rejected this. Zwingli reduced it to mere symbolism. And today, most Protestants treat communion as nothing more than a memorial meal.

Think about what this means. Jesus said, "Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you." If you believe communion is just bread and grape juice, you're not receiving Christ. You're going through the motions while missing the actual supernatural food Christ gave us.

Can God save someone who doesn't receive the Eucharist through no fault of their own? Yes. But if you've been shown the truth about the Eucharist and you reject it? You're rejecting Christ's own words. You're saying no to the food He said you must eat to have life.

The Destruction of the Sacramental System

The sacraments aren't decorative additions. They're how Christ dispenses His grace. Baptism regenerates. Confirmation strengthens. The Eucharist nourishes. Confession restores. Anointing prepares for death. Holy Orders continues apostolic ministry. Matrimony sanctifies marriage.

Protestantism gutted this system. Most Protestants recognize only two sacraments. And even those they've reduced to symbols rather than means of grace.

But here's the critical problem: what happens when you sin after your once-saved-always-saved moment?

Catholics go to confession. We confess our sins to a priest who has the authority Christ gave to His apostles. We receive absolution. Our souls are washed clean. Sanctifying grace is restored. We walk out knowing our sins are forgiven.

Protestants? They're told to confess directly to God. No sacrament. No absolution. No concrete assurance. Just vague hope.

But Christ gave His apostles the authority to forgive sins. After His resurrection, He appeared to them and said, "Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you withhold forgiveness from any, it is withheld."

This wasn't symbolic. This was Christ instituting the sacrament of reconciliation. That power continues today through apostolic succession.

When you reject this, you're rejecting a means of grace Christ instituted. You're cutting yourself off from the ordinary means by which God restores souls after mortal sin.

The Faith Alone Heresy and the Denial of Works

Protestants quote Ephesians: "For by grace you have been saved through faith, and this is not your own doing, it is the gift of God, not a result of works."

They're right. We are saved by grace through faith. Catholics believe this completely.

But then Protestants add a word Paul never wrote: alone. They say we're saved by faith alone. And here's where the danger creeps in.

Paul says we're saved by faith apart from works of the law, meaning ceremonial requirements of the Old Covenant. He never says we're saved apart from all works, from obedience, from living righteously. Paul constantly emphasizes holy living.

And James makes it explicit: "You see that a person is justified by works and not by faith alone." That's the only time the phrase "faith alone" appears in Scripture, and it says the opposite of what Protestantism teaches. James says faith without works is dead.

The Catholic understanding is that faith, hope, and charity work together. Faith is the foundation. But it must be faith working through love. It must be a living faith that produces good works, not to earn salvation, but as the natural fruit of grace.

Protestantism's faith alone doctrine has produced a generation of Christians who think their moral lives don't matter. Who believe they can live any way they want because they're covered by grace. Who commit grave sins without fear because they said the magic words thirty years ago.

This is what Dietrich Bonhoeffer called cheap grace. Grace without discipleship. Grace without the cross.

Once Saved, Always Saved: The Most Dangerous Lie

This doctrine didn't exist until John Calvin invented it in the sixteenth century. Even Luther didn't teach it. For fifteen hundred years, Christianity taught that salvation can be lost through mortal sin and apostasy.

But Calvin argued that if you're truly elect, you cannot lose salvation. You might fall into sin, but you'll always come back. And if you don't come back? You were never really saved.

Do you see the trap? It's unfalsifiable. It creates false security that lulls souls to sleep while they're sliding toward damnation.

The Bible is filled with warnings about falling away. Hebrews speaks of those who were once enlightened, who tasted the heavenly gift, who became partakers of the Holy Spirit, and then fell away. Paul warns the Corinthians that he disciplines his body lest he himself should be disqualified. He tells the Galatians that they are severed from Christ if they seek justification by law, that they have fallen from grace.

These aren't hypothetical warnings. Real Christians can really fall away and really be lost.

The Catholic Church teaches that we can have moral certainty of salvation if we're in a state of grace, living faithfully, receiving the sacraments, avoiding mortal sin. But absolute certainty? No. Because we're still free. We can still reject God. We must work out our salvation with fear and trembling, as Paul says.

The Removal of Seven Books From Scripture

When Martin Luther translated the Bible into German, he removed seven books from the Old Testament: Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, and First and Second Maccabees. He also removed portions of Daniel and Esther.

Why did he do this? Doctrinal reasons. These books taught things Luther rejected.

Second Maccabees twelve talks about Judas Maccabeus making atonement for Jewish soldiers who had fallen in battle. When they found pagan amulets under the tunics of the dead, Judas turned to supplication, praying that the sin might be wholly blotted out. He took up a collection and sent it to Jerusalem to provide for a sin offering for the dead.

This passage implies that prayers and sacrifices for the dead are efficacious. It suggests that some purification or atonement can occur after death for those who die with lesser sins. This is the biblical foundation for the Catholic doctrine of purgatory.

Luther rejected purgatory. Therefore, he had to remove the books that supported it. He relegated them to an appendix in his Bible, calling them Apocrypha.

But these books had been in the Bible since before the time of Christ. They were in the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Old Testament that Jesus and the apostles used. The earliest Greek manuscripts of the Old Testament include them. The Church councils at Hippo and Carthage in the late fourth century listed them as Scripture.

For eleven hundred years, Christians read these books as inspired Scripture. Then Luther came along and cut them out because they contradicted his new doctrines.

Think about what else these books teach. Tobit speaks of angels and their intercessory role. It speaks of almsgiving and good works. Wisdom speaks of the immortality of the soul and coming judgment. Sirach is filled with wisdom about living righteously. The Books of Maccabees record the heroic faith of Jews who died rather than abandon God's law.

When Protestants removed these books, they lost key teachings about the afterlife, the communion of saints, the value of good works, and the reality of spiritual warfare.

Ten Ways Protestant Life Can Lead to Damnation

Let me lay this out as clearly as I can. These are concrete ways that living as a Protestant can place your immortal soul in danger:

One: Rejecting the Eucharist after learning it's truly Christ's Body and Blood. Jesus said unless you eat His flesh and drink His blood, you have no life in you. If you refuse to receive the Eucharist after being taught the truth, you're refusing the food Christ said is necessary.

Two: Persisting in grave sin without sacramental confession. When you commit mortal sin, you fall from grace. You need reconciliation. Private confession isn't the means Christ established. He gave His apostles the power to forgive sins sacramentally. If you reject this and continue in mortal sin, you're on the road to Hell.

Three: Refusing to enter the Catholic Church despite recognizing it may be true. If you've seen the evidence, studied the history, encountered Catholic teaching, and you still refuse to enter, that's not invincible ignorance. That's culpable rejection of grace.

Four: Adopting once saved always saved and ceasing to fight sin. When you believe nothing can separate you from God, you stop vigilance. You think you can dabble in sin without consequences. You're wrong. Mortal sin still damns.

Five: Treating faith as mere emotional experience. Many Protestants reduce salvation to a feeling, an emotional moment. But faith isn't a feeling. It's trust that produces obedience. It's faithfulness that endures to the end.

Six: Denying the authority of the Church Christ founded. When you reject the magisterium, when you elevate private interpretation over the Church's teaching authority, you're saying Christ didn't know what He was doing. You're setting yourself up as your own pope.

Seven: Rejecting sacramental grace as works-based religion. Protestants often refuse the sacraments because they think receiving grace through physical means diminishes the cross. But God chose to work through matter. He became flesh. Rejecting sacraments is rejecting the means of grace He established.

Eight: Clinging to private interpretation over revealed doctrine. When you insist on reading Scripture without submission to the Church's teaching authority, you inevitably fall into error. The Ethiopian eunuch couldn't understand Isaiah until Philip explained it. You can't rightly interpret Scripture without the Church.

Nine: Treating sin as irrelevant because Jesus paid it all. Yes, Christ's sacrifice is sufficient. But that doesn't mean sin doesn't matter. Mortal sin kills grace. Unrepented sin damns. Christ paid the price, but we must accept His grace and live accordingly.

Ten: Living without sanctifying grace due to absence of sacramental life. Sanctifying grace is the supernatural life of God in the soul. It's normally received and maintained through the sacraments. Without sacramental life, you're trying to live the Christian life in your own power. And you cannot.

The Difference Grace Makes

I've seen the difference firsthand. I've watched Protestants struggle with sin, bound by the same vices year after year, never breaking free. Because they don't have confession. They don't have the Eucharist. They don't have the sanctifying grace that flows through sacramental life.

Then I've watched those same people become Catholic. Encounter the real presence. Go to confession for the first time. Receive the grace that actually transforms. And their lives change. Not perfectly. Not overnight. But truly.

Because grace isn't just God being nice to us. Grace is God's own life in our souls. It's supernatural power. It's the Holy Spirit dwelling in us, transforming us from the inside out. And it flows primarily through the sacraments Christ instituted.

The Catholic faith isn't about rules and regulations. It's not about earning your way to Heaven. It's about receiving the fullness of what Christ offers through His Church. It's about being nourished by His Body and Blood. It's about having your sins truly forgiven in sacramental reconciliation. It's about having every moment of your life sanctified through the sacraments.

The Hope That Remains

Before you think I'm saying all Protestants are going to Hell, let me be clear: I'm not. God's mercy is infinite. God judges the heart. Many Protestants love Jesus with sincere devotion and live according to the light they've been given.

The Church teaches that those who through no fault of their own don't know the Catholic Church is Christ's Church may still be saved. God can save anyone He wills. He's not limited by the sacraments He instituted, though we are.

But here's the critical question: Is your ignorance truly invincible? Have you been shown the truth and rejected it? Have you encountered the Catholic Church and dismissed it without serious investigation? Have you assumed the lies you learned about Catholicism are true without actually studying what the Church teaches?

Because if you've been given the grace to see the truth and you reject it, you're rejecting Christ. If you've been shown that the Catholic Church is the Church He founded and you refuse to enter, you're refusing His call. If you've learned about the real presence and you still treat communion as a symbol, you're rejecting the food He said you must eat.

The question isn't whether God can save Protestants. The question is whether you're willing to accept all the grace He offers.

The Call Home

If you're reading this as a Protestant, I'm not trying to scare you into the Catholic Church. Fear alone isn't enough. What I'm trying to do is wake you up to the stakes.

Your soul is on the line. Your eternity hangs in the balance. And the comfortable lies of Protestantism, the easy promises of once saved always saved, the reduction of Christianity to a decision you made and a feeling you had, might be robbing you of the fullness of grace Christ died to give you.

The Catholic Church is here. The Church Christ founded two thousand years ago. With apostolic succession unbroken from Peter to the current pope. With the sacraments Christ instituted. With the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist. With the power to forgive sins. With the fullness of truth preserved by the Holy Spirit.

You don't have to keep gambling your salvation on Protestant innovations from the sixteenth century. You don't have to keep relying on your own private interpretation. You don't have to keep going through symbolic communion when you could receive Christ Himself.

Come home. Enter the Church. Receive the Eucharist. Go to confession. Live sacramentally. Stop playing Russian roulette with your immortal soul.

Because the truth is this: you're not saved by saying magic words. You're not saved by a one-time decision. You're not guaranteed Heaven because you prayed a prayer. You're saved by the grace of Jesus Christ, received through faith and the sacraments, lived out in obedience and love, persevering to the end.

That's the Gospel. That's the faith once delivered to the saints. That's what the Church has always taught.

And your soul is too precious to settle for anything less.

A Final Warning

Hell is real. Jesus spoke about it more than He spoke about Heaven. The fire that never goes out. The worm that doesn't die. The outer darkness where there's weeping and gnashing of teeth. The eternal separation from God.

And mortal sin leads there. Apostasy leads there. Rejecting known truth leads there. Refusing the grace God offers leads there.

The Catholic Church doesn't want anyone to go to Hell. God doesn't want anyone to perish. He desires all men to be saved and to come to knowledge of the truth. But He won't force anyone. He gave us free will. And with that free will comes the terrifying possibility of choosing Hell.

Protestantism, with its easy believism, its once saved always saved comfort, its reduction of salvation to a moment rather than a journey, its rejection of the sacraments and the Church, makes it far too easy to sleepwalk into damnation while thinking you're secure.

Don't let that be your story. Don't let comfortable lies about eternal security lull you to sleep while you're heading for the cliff. Don't reject the Church Christ founded. Don't refuse the Eucharist He gave us. Don't live without the sanctifying grace that flows through the sacraments.

The path is narrow. Few find it. The gate is small. Many will say Lord, Lord on that day, and He will say He never knew them. Not everyone who says "Lord, Lord" will enter Heaven, but only the one who does the will of the Father.

Are you doing His will? Or are you following the traditions of men that make void the word of God? Are you in His Church? Or have you separated yourself from the Body of Christ? Are you receiving His Body and Blood? Or are you settling for symbols and empty rituals?

These questions matter. They matter eternally.

Your soul depends on getting them right.

So here it is, without sugar-coating, without soft edges, without the padded pew comfort of easy religion:

Come home.

Come back to the Church Christ built on rock, not sand.
Come back to apostolic faith, not personal opinion.
Come back to the altar where Heaven bends low and the Lamb of God is made present.
Come back to the confessional where chains are snapped and sins are cast into the abyss.
Come back to the one flock, under the one Shepherd, not the marketplace of denominations and doctrinal guesses.

You were not made for spiritual minimalism. You were not made for sermons and coffee bars and theological sound bites. You were made for the blazing furnace of God’s love poured out in the sacraments. You were made for the Mass, for Calvary breaking into time, for the angels and saints surrounding the altar while the priest whispers the words that shake Hell itself.

You were made for the Eucharist.

If your heart is burning right now, that is not manipulation. That is not theatrics. That is not my voice. That is the Holy Spirit pounding on the door you have kept shut for years because conversion costs something. Pride must die. Preconceptions must die. The comfortable lie must die.

Let it die.

Christ did not ask you to say a prayer and then coast. He asked you to take up your cross and follow Him — all the way, not halfway, not in theory, not in the denomination of your preference. He built a Church and He meant you to be inside it, not circling around it with excuses and theological slogans.

You are not being called to “switch churches.” You are being called to return to the Body of Christ itself — to the only place on earth where the fullness of the faith, the fullness of truth, and the fullness of the sacraments can be found.

So stop running.

If you have been baptized, God has already marked you as His own. Now step into the fullness of what that baptism was meant to lead you to. If you have been away, if you left angry, if you were wounded or confused or scandalized — come anyway. The saints were sinners who came home and stayed.

Do not trade eternity for comfort. Do not trade the Real Presence for crackers and grape juice. Do not trade apostolic authority for the noise of a thousand pulpits contradicting one another while calling it unity.

Come home to Rome.

Walk into a Catholic church. Kneel. Ask Christ what He wants. Go to RCIA. Talk to a priest. Go to confession if you are Catholic already and have been away. Stop inventing reasons to delay. Souls are not guaranteed tomorrows.

He is waiting for you — not as a symbol, not as a memory, but as the living God in the tabernacle, silent and burning with love, patient beyond all measure, wounded by your absence, longing for your return.

Choose. Not someday. Now.

Because Heaven and Hell are not metaphors, and you do not get infinite chances.

Come home to the Catholic Church.
Come to the Eucharist.
Come to the Bride of Christ.
Come while there is still time.

~by Jeff Callaway

Texas Outlaw Poet

© 2026 Texas Outlaw Press. All rights reserved.

https://texasoutlawpress.org